The guncontrol debate, explained in 5 questions the. The information and statistics all seem to contradict each other, and everyone has such strong opinions about guns that there must be a right one. These documents provide a compelling view of what the ongoing debate surrounding guns and a wellregulated militia, as gun owners and advocates argue in favor of the protection of second amendment rights and those in favor of gun control argue for increased efforts to limit gun ownership in an effort to reduce gun violence and mass shootings. A debate on gun control was held between second amendment expert david kopel and gun control advocate arnie grossman. Living with guns a liberals case for the second amendment by craig r. From a gun culture that took root early in american history to the mass shootings that repeatedly bring the public discussion of gun control to a fever pitch, the topic has preoccupied citizens, public officials, and special interest groups for decades. The gun debate facts on background checks, concealedcarry laws, u. The background and pro and con arguments were written by staff based upon input from the following footnotes directly referenced and sources used for general research and not directly referenced. Dec 03, 2015 the guncontrol debate, explained in 5 questions. Mar 05, 2018 the gun debate facts on background checks, concealedcarry laws, u. Bovy tackles the gun issue by arguing that the debate should not be about closing loopholes in gun control. She doesnt argue that specific types of guns should be banned, but argues that all guns should be banned this article is published by new republic, which was founded in 1914 as a journal of opinion which seeks to meet the challenge of a new time. In doing so, he takes on and debunks the common myths and outright lies that are often used to vilify guns and demean their owners.
Senate passes a bill requiring trigger locks on all newly manufactured handguns and extending waiting period and background check requirements to sales of firearms at gun shows. High school and undergraduate students can use this resourceone of the largest collections of key documents concerning the issue of gun controlto explore the seminal arguments for and against further. Although already a bit dated this book was published in 1990, this collection of essays contains many of the classics in the gun control debate including sanford levinsons classic the embarrassing second amendment as well as the infamous 43to1 study by arthur kellerman. But the 2008 edition of gun digest buyers guide to assault weapons, a book for gun enthusiasts, lays out a pretty specific definition. Semiautomatic rifles that accept detachable magazines holding more than 10 rounds of ammunition, and often include. These questions frame the deeper debate between gun rights defenders such as nras david keene and gun control advocates like sen. Gun control has continued to be widely debated, however, and has often been opposed, notably by the national rifle association nra. Minimizing the use of guns may not diminish the crimes because it is on the hands of the user that matters. Sport hunting while gun control is a hot topic for debate, many across the nation are pointing to sport hunting as an example of responsible gun ownership. Two important arguments from both sides of the gun debate. A constitutional case for gun control the atlantic.
There are as many guns in the united states as there are adults. The public health rationale for gun control is clear. Gun control in america is really a big debate and this book has tackled this topic perfectly. Public health arguments for gun control psychology today. The popular view of the american revolution holds that the colonists fought the british for liberty and freedom, and against tyranny. One of the most divisive issues in america today, the debate over gun control comes into full view following a tragic event like sundays church shooting. In the united states the right of the people to keep and bear arms is guaranteed by the constitution, but has been variously interpreted through the years. Here are a few important gun control pros and cons. Constitution, which reads, a well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed. If you only read one book about the gun debate in america, it should be this one. Gun control laws and lower gun ownership rates do not prevent suicides.
In the us the number of deaths and attendant costs are much higher. The point is that the right to bear arms is not the only constitutional commitment implicated in the guns debate, and the court ought to consider those. There are no easy answers to the debate about gun control. Aug 05, 2019 the gun rights versus gun control debate in the us touches on a wide range of cultural and political issues that go much deeper than the question of access to firearms. Saul cornell and nathan dedino, a well regulated right. What everyone needs to know delves into the issues that americans debate when they talk about guns.
How changes in the gun industry are killing americans and what it will take to stop it hardcover by. In a library, books representing the spectrum of the debate await on our. A debate and discussion must be had, since discussion can aid us in. He opens by specifying what he means by gun control. In gun control debate, several options draw major support, jan. The attack renews debate on the need for more restrictive gun control laws. Guns in america, the full debate, more guns less problems. Popular gun control books meet your next favorite book. In defense of gun control hardcover hugh lafollette. At the end of the twentieth century and into the twentyfirst, highly publicized gun massacres, especially in schools, have maintained gun control as a hotly contested, peculiarly american. Still, the book is an important read even for gun control advocates. Aug 15, 2016 with this in mind, ive sourced 12 gun control articles from online publications that illustrate both sides of the debate, plus two articles that can help you understand the background of the issue.
What everyone needs to know delves into the issues that americans. Goss thoroughly cover the latest research, data, and developments on gun ownership, gun violence, the firearms. Lithuania has one of the worlds lowest gun ownership rates 0. The first part of the book is devoted to hunts arguments against gun control.
The guncontrol debate is one of the most dishonest arguments we have in american politics. Mar 12, 2020 the gun debate is written in an admirably neutral tone. The availability of guns is controlled by nations and localities throughout the world. The gun debate is written in an admirably neutral tone. Philosophy professor unpacks the debate over gun control. On march 9, 2018, florida governor rick scott signed into law the marjory stoneman douglas high school public safety act, a move that surprised those on all sides of the gun reform debate, as it marked the first gun control legislation passed in that state in decades. The history of the us gun control debate explained historyextra. What goes on when everybody thinks nobodys watching, ucdmc.
Advocates on this side of the debate propose measures such as stricter eligibility requirements for age and mental he. Gun owners in texas cast a wary eye on gun control debate nation. Summarizing results from hundreds of studies, the book makes a hugely positive contribution toward sensitive and sensible evidencebased evaluation of what has worked, and what hasnt, in gun control and why. In defense of gun control hardcover hugh lafollette oxford university press.
The majority of historians and factcheckers have described the argument as dubious, questionable, preposterous, tendentious, or problematic. These books will make you think differently about the gun. Goss wrote the definitive study of why the gun control movement has failed so far. This argument is frequently employed by opponents of gun control in debates on. Gun control, politics, legislation, and enforcement of measures intended to restrict access to, the possession of, or the use of arms, particularly firearms.
This book offers an inside look at the life of a survivor, while also discussing the couples perspective on the gun control debate and the governments role in. In control, glenn beck presents a passionate, factbased case for guns that reveals why gun control isnt really about controlling guns at all. May 17, 2019 gun control is typically viewed as one of the most polarizing subjects in political discourse today. Gun control is the next major item on new york states justice reform agenda, with six bills up for debate in the state legislature and more than two dozen others under consideration. The gun rights versus gun control debate in the us touches on a wide range of cultural and political issues that go much deeper than the question of access to firearms. According to the bureau of alcohol, tobacco, firearms and explosives, in 2017 there were an estimated 393 million guns in the u. Both the history of the gun control debate, as well as the focus the debate will take in the future, are explored in this unique collection of over 200 documents spanning 200 years.
Advocates on this side of the debate propose measures such as stricter eligibility requirements. Sep 17, 2019 gun owners in texas cast a wary eye on gun control debate nation. These books will make you think differently about the gun control. This is where this book on gun control comes to help. Gunfight, by ucla constitutional law professor adam winkler, has many conclusions that will confuse and irritate. Jul, 2016 sport hunting while gun control is a hot topic for debate, many across the nation are pointing to sport hunting as an example of responsible gun ownership. This book has a great sense of righteousness and equality in every statement it gives. The gun control debate is more complex than we often acknowledge. To many, the answer is to enact more restrictions on legal access to firearms. The what everyone needs to know subtitle means the gun debate is part of a book series published by oxford university press that covers a range of topics from adhd to venezuela. Data sources gun control and gun rights library at. What everyone needs to know delves into the issues that americans debate. A short reading list to make your gun debate smarter. For each article, ive included the authors basic point and why the article is a worthwhile resource, as well as citations for apa and mla.
The empirical evidence 56 5 the victims and the bene. Increasing gun related crimes together with citizen pressure propelled congressional passage 1993 of the brady bill named for james brady, the press secretary seriously wounded in the 1981 assassination. May 20, 1999 by a 5150 vote, with the tiebreaker vote cast by vice president al gore, the u. Discusses the history of guns and gun control in the united states, relevant laws and legal cases, and the arguments posed by both sides in the debate about. Lax gun control laws are economically costly the coalition for gun control claims that, in canada, the costs of firearms death and injury including murder, suicide and unintentional injuries alone have been estimated at 6 billion dollars per year. High school and undergraduate students can use this resourceone of the largest collections of key documents concerning the issue of gun control to explore the. With a balanced and broadranging approach, noted economist philip j. According to the national crime victimization survey ncvs in 2005, 477,040 victims of violent crimes stated that they faced an offender with a firearm. Petersburg professor is looking to inject some nuance into the highlycharged debate over firearms and how they should be used.
Behind gun control debate, questions of whats practical. Ppt gun control debate powerpoint presentation free to. Oct 28, 2019 a constitutional case for gun control. The gun control debate is one of the most dishonest arguments we have in american politics. Oct 05, 2017 this book offers an inside look at the life of a survivor, while also discussing the couples perspective on the gun control debate and the governments role in solving the issue. What is often phrased as a single question should we have gun control is actually made up of three distinct policy questions. The history of the us gun control debate explained. Popular gun control books showing 150 of 81 the last gun. The nazi gun control argument is a belief that gun regulations in the third reich helped to facilitate the rise of the nazis and the holocaust. Arming yourself against gun control lies, john lott methodically dismantles one popular guncontrol myth after another.
Columbine and other highly publicized shootings have kept ame. The guncontrol debate in the united states also necessarily concerns the proper interpretation of the second amendment to the u. This book, presents the issue with both sides of the debate on all the issues. List of books and articles about gun control online. Jan 17, 20 two important arguments from both sides of the gun debate. In this thoroughly revised second edition of the gun debate. Philosophy professor unpacks the debate over gun control in. It is dishonest in its particulars, of course, but it is in an important sense dishonest in general. Here are three books that bring intellectual rigor and analysis to both sides of the american gun control debate. Gun control is one of the most controversial and emotional issues in many countries, with the debate often centring on whether regulations on an individuals right to arms are an undue restriction on liberty and whether there. Gun owners in texas cast a wary eye on gun control debate. Acts of gun violence, particularly mass shootings of unarmed innocents, shake us to our core. This page will be safe for the rational and the sane, a no harassment zone. Incidents involving a firearm represented 9 of the 4.
In this mythbusting book on gun violence, director of the harvard injury control research. Oct 08, 2015 still, the book is an important read even for gun control advocates. He writes generally from a negative outcomes and gun regulation perspective. Lotts assumptions are worth examining, particularly his concept of an acceptable level of deaths. Gun policy is among the most controversial topics in the united states. States with higher percentages of households owning guns tend to have higher gun fatality rates. Gun control pros and cons have been discussed and thoroughly analyzed in gun control debates innumerable times, but both advocates and opponents of gun control have stuck to their positions, leaving the issue unresolved.
88 1217 931 673 780 720 805 488 100 233 1287 790 1343 509 1073 505 281 1111 706 537 955 1290 693 605 875 183 257 285 1005 171 289 733 1342